Best Dog Training Collar Reviews 2017

According to best dog training collar reviews 2017, they have become very popular among pet owners. They have been used to train pet dogs on different behavior issues which include excessive barking or jumping at people. When it comes to shopping for the best for your pet dog, it can be quite difficult.

There are many brands in the market which have unique features and accessories. It is important to read through our (Dog Collar Zone) buyers guide and learn more. This will help you to improve on your choice and allow you to make the best selection.

What you need to know is that every dog can be trained but with patience. Using top dog training collars, one can finally achieve their goal. Before reading the details review, see the bellow given comparison table at a glance. 

Our Top Pick

Garmin Delta Sports XC​

Garmin Delta Sports XC

Click Here for More Photos


Editor Recommendation: 3 Top Rated Dog Training Collars 2017-

SportDog SD425 Collar

SportDog SD425 remote dog training collar reviews

Editor Rating:

  • Cutting edge technology
  • Range- 500 yard
  • ​​Stimulation- 7 levels
  • Tone & vibration mode
  • Training manual & DVD
  • Waterproof up to 25 feet

Garmin Delta Sports XC​

Garmin Delta Sports XC

Editor Rating:

  • Tri-Tronics technology
  • Range- 3/4 mile
  • ​Stimulation- 36 levels
  • 5 training configurations
  • Tone & vibration mode
  • LCD display

Dogtra 300M Element

Dogtra 300M302M training collar reviews

Editor Rating:

  • ​5/8’’ contact points
  • Range- ½ a mile
  • Stimulation 0-100 level
  • Battery life indicator
  • Pager mode-waterproof
  • 2 year warranty


Before Purchasing the Dog Training Collar 

What is a dog training collar?

This refers to a collar that is fitted with electronic components and can be controlled via a wireless remote. The dog training collar comes in three forms – shock based, Citronella solution based and Ultrasonic sound based. It is wrapped around the neck of a pet dog to help the owner train it.

How do dog training collars work?

Dog training collars consist of two components – a handheld remote transmitter and an electronic receiver collar. The electronic receiver collar is wrapped around the neck of the dog while the owner controls the pet. The handheld remote control device comes with different types of stimulations which allow the home owner to train the dog. It also has a dial which allows one to set the strength of static correction. The collar has two prongs which initiate the static correction when the owner uses the remote control device. With this combination, the pet owner finally has a way of training their pet dog.

Benefits of dog training collars.

Controls your pet dog barking- Majority of dogs do bark uncontrollably and when this happens, you will definitely have potential problems with your close friends and neighbors. When you fit your dog with the collar it will help to control the barking behavior. When the dog barks, a static correction signal will be triggered every time.

Prevents your dog from jumping on people- Dogs love to jump and it is their way of showing affection to people familiar with them. Just like other pets, dogs spend most of their time playing in the dirt. This means their paws will be coated with dust and other particles. When they jump on you, they will surely stain your clothes. The dog collar helps to prevent this behavior.

Dog Training collar review & benefits

Controls a dog aggression- There are dogs which are very aggressive which makes them to be unpredictable and may harm you or your family members. With the dog collar, you can be able to prevent this behavior with time. The aggressive behavior is not suitable and your dog needs to learn this. You can apply wireless dog collars which will help control the aggressive behavior.

Prevent destructive chewing- There are moments when your dog starts to chew stuff in your home. From dolls to furniture foam and this behavior is not acceptable. One way you can control this is by using a dog training collar. Every time your dog starts to chew on something other than food, you can stimulate the static correction. This will prevent the dog from doing so in time.

Prevents digging- As a home owner, you have invested in landscaping the yard. This is an expensive venture and in the end, it transforms the look of your property. Dogs are known to dig around the yard when hiding bones or other things. This will definitely damage the investment you have made on your lawn. To stop this behavior, you can use the dog training collar.

How to choose the best dog training collars in 2017?

There are factors that one needs to consider before choosing a dog training collar and they include;

Comfort- When buying a dog collar, you need to ensure that it’s comfortable. This is because it will be worn at all times. You need to research and find out which dog collar is suitable for your dog. It is important to know that no collar will work if the dog will not tolerate it.

Read product reviews- Take your time to research online and look for websites that host reviews from past customers. This will allow you to know which brand or dog collar type is suitable for you. One place you can start looking is at eCommerce stores.

Purchase the right type with temperament in mind- It is wise to recognize that your dog is exclusive and will respond to different stimuli. If your dog is relaxed, you need a less powerful collar. If it’s aggressive, you will need a collar with a powerful jolt.

Match the functions to the surrounding- You need to confirm that a particular collar is great for your dog. You need to think about dog size, age group and the environment. You need also to understand that ultrasonic collars will have an impact on other dogs inside your home.

9 Top Rated Dog Training Collars Comparison Table-

Training Collar NameRangeStimulationKey FeaturePrice
Garmin Delta Sports XC
(Best Choice)
3/4 Mile36 levelsTri-Tronics technology
SportDog SD-425 Field Trainer
(Budget Choice)
500 Yard7 levelsWaterproof up to 25 feet
Dogtra 300m Element
(Best Value)
½ a Mile0-100 levelsPager mode & 2 years warranty
Educator E-Collar
(Best Value 2)
½ a Mile1-100 levelPavlovian tone
PetSafe Yard Training Collar
(Best Value 3)
400 yard8 levelsTrains up to 3 dogs
Pet Resolve Dog Training Kits
(Best Budget 2)
3/4 Mile10 levels Comes with free eBook & USB adaptor
Garmin Pro 70 Dog Training System
100 Yard6 levels Built-in BarkLimiter & 70 handheld
Lobo Commander Training Collar
(Under $100)
400 Yard16 levels Has lifetime warranty
PetTech Remote Controlled Training Collar
(Under $50)
1200 Foot1-100 levelLCD remote & adjustable shock


Top 7 Dog Training Collar Reviews


Garmin Delta Sports XC Review (Best Training Collar for Dogs)

Garmin Delta Sports XC

Click Here for More Photos

Editor Rating:

The dog training device has the following specifications:

  • It has an easy to use 3 button handheld controller that comes with improved false correction control.
  • It is fitted with an easy to read LCD display.
  • It utilizes the Tri-Tronics technology which allows dog trainers more control and simplicity.
  • It has 36 professional levels of continuous and momentary stimulation.
  • It has the ability of training 1, 2 or 3 dogs from up to three quarters of a mile.

The Garmin Delta Sport XC dog training device comes with the Tri-Tronics technology. This technology allows dog trainers to have more control over their pet dogs. It also makes the use of the device simple. With the easy to use 3 button handheld controller, the dog trainer can control up to 3 dogs. To achieve this, it is necessary to purchase additional dog devices.

The handheld controller has the improved false correction control and is fitted with an easy to read LCD display. The dog training collar is a compact device with changeable contact points that allows for 36 professional levels of continuous and momentary stimulation.

It has the fully adjustable BarkLimiter with Advanced Bark correction making it one of the most effective dog training devices especially against barking. This assures you of no noise that would have been brought about by excessive barking. You can finally experience peace and friendly neighbors.


  • Thanks to the Tri-Tronics technology it comes with, the dog trainer is able to use the device easier.
  • It is fitted with an easy to read LCD display that provides vital data regarding stimulation levels and others.
  • The easy to use handheld device has improved false correction control and can help to train up to 3 dogs.
  • You can finally control the barking thanks to the Barklimiter with Advanced Bark Correction.
  • It is a compact device that has changeable contact points both long and short. This gives you 36 professional levels of continuous and momentary stimulation.


  • While the dog training device allows you to train up to 3 dogs, you need to purchase additional collars which are expensive.
  • The response of the handheld controller is slow especially when it comes to activating a dog collar. This means the further away the dog is, the longer the reaction time.
  • The LCD display generates a bright light which interferes with the dog owner’s night vision.

The Garmin Delta Sport XC is a great dog training device with Tri-Tronic technology and easy to use handheld controller. It has 36 settings for both continuous and momentary stimulation. The easy to read LCD displays the right data always.


SportDog SD-425 Review (Best Training Collar)

SportDog SD425 remote dog training collar reviews

Click Here for More Photos

Editor Rating:

The best remote dog training collar has the following specifications:

  • It weighs 3.3 ounces making it light.
  • It is a combo pack that includes a dog training device and whistle kit.
  • It has cutting edge technology that improves training.
  • It is waterproof up to 25 feet when submerged underwater.
  • It comes with a training manual and DVD.

This is a bundle pack that consists of a PetsTEK dog training clicker and a dog whistle training kit. The combination of both is designed to give the dog owner a set of useful tools to teach their pet dog new behavior.

It is one of the most cutting edge training collars which has the newly improved and lightweight receiver. The collar weighs 3.3 ounces which is light and has a strap for fastening. The dog owner can control the dog up to a distance of 500 yards away. This makes the dog training kit perfect for use on the field or around the yard.

It is designed to work and ensures positive reinforcement after use. It does not require a lot of experience to use especially when combined with the whistle kit. It allows the dog owner to train their pet dog to the fullest potential.

It is widely known that dogs not only have a great sense of smell but hearing too. With the whistle kit, the dog will be easier to control than with the human voice.


  • It comes with a training manual and DVD which makes it easier to use.
  • It is lightweight and weighs only 3.3 ounces.
  • It comes as a bundle pack that includes the dog training device and whistle pack.
  • It is waterproof up to 25 feet when submerged in water.
  • You can train your dog to the fullest potential thanks to the bundle pack.


  • It uses a charging adaptor which means the battery will be depleted while in the field making it ineffective.
  • The use of the dog collar and whistle pack will send mixed signals to the dog.
  • Can only control one dog only.

If you are looking for the ultimate training kit for your dog, then you have found it. The SportDog SD425 comes as a bundle pack – dog training kit and whistle kit. It comes with a training manual, DVD, operating guide, charging adaptor, test light and Lanyard.


Dogtra 300m Review (Best Training Collar for Small Dogs)

Dogtra 300M302M training collar reviews

Click for More Photos

Editor Rating:

You will like Dogtra 300M/302M for the following specifications:

  • It has a range of ½ a mile.
  • It has no LCD display.
  • It is available in 2 dog unit.
  • It has the pager mode.
  • It is fully waterproof – collar and transmitter.

The Dogtra 300M/302M is a great training kit that helps to elicit better behavior management especially for mild mannered dogs. In the package, you will find a transmitter, a receiver with 5/8’’ contact points, a battery charger, splitter cable, owner’s manual and Lanyard.

It has precise stimulation levels which help to elicit different behaviors and control mechanism. It has a reduced receiver which is designed to fit smaller dogs. The owner can be able to control the dog from a distance of ½ a mile. It comes with rechargeable user replaceable Ni-MH batteries.

With a 2 year warranty which is limited and lifetime, the dog owner is assured of replacement incase it is damaged. The collar is waterproof plus the transmitter. This means it can be used in the rain and if it is submerged in water, the electric components will be protected.

The 302M version comes in a 2 dog unit which allows the owner to train two dogs at once.


  • It has the user replaceable and rechargeable Ni-MH batteries.
  • The collar and transmitter are fully water proof.
  • It comes with a 2 year limited lifetime warranty which assures the owner of repairs or replacement.
  • It has an LED battery life indicator.
  • It comes with a battery charger and splitter cable.


  • It comes with no carry case.
  • It does not have an LCD display
  • 300M unit is not expandable which means it can only be used on one dog.

If you are looking for a fully waterproof, with rechargeable and user replaceable batteries, then the Dogtra 300M/302M is the best choice. It comes with a 2 year limited lifetime warranty with an LED battery life indicator. You can use the owner’s manual to understand how it works.


Educator E-Collar Remote Dog Training Collar Review

Educator E-Collar Remote Dog Training Collar Review

Click for More Images

Editor Rating:

Educator E-Collar Remote Dog Training Collar has the following specifications:

  • For Dogs 5 Pounds and up.
  • Adjustable Booster Buttons.
  • Lock and Set Safety Feature.
  • Remote LED Tracking Light.
  • Floating Transmitter.
  • Waterproof to 500 Feet.
  • Pavlovian Tone.

The Mini Educator is known as one of the most humane and successful training devices on the market, and is classified as a 1/2 mile range remote dog trainer. If you are concerned about a humane collar, than this is an excellent choice for you, as the 'lock and set' feature lets the trainer lock in the stimulation level. The stress free blunt stimulation in this collar means that your dog will not feel the sharp shock found in traditional shock collars.

The COS, or control of stimulation technology is reliable, providing a tapping sensation rather than a vibration, which most people find works rather well. The Pavlovian Tone is an excellent feature for training as well and creates a 1-1/2 second tone, followed by the stimulation. As a result, the dog will soon respond only to the tone. You also have the ability to select stimulation levels from 1 to 100 to get the perfect results.

The Mini Educator is a small, ergonomic and discrete transmitter at 2 x 1.5 x 1 inches. For those times when you need to take your dog out in the dark, the Mini Educator has a night tracking light on the collar, which is controlled by the transmitter. The lost transmitter beeper is handy in locating a lost transmitter.

The receiver and transmitter is waterproof and the transmitter will float if dropped in the water. The lithium-polymer rechargeable batteries with dual charger give 2 hours on a full charge. The Mini Educator 1/2 Mile Remote Dog Training Collar comes with a 2 year full manufacturer’s warranty.


  • Stress free blunt stimulation.
  • Ergonomic, water proof transmitter.
  • Night tracking light on collar.
  • Pavlovian tone.
  • COS provides a tapping sensation.


  • Battery life is short.
  • Instruction manual may be too detailed for some users.

The Educator E-Collar Remote Dog Training Collar easily assists in training dogs 5 pounds and up. The ergonomic transmitter has a stopwatch type interface for ease of control. The transmitter delivers a tapping sensation instead of a vibration with stimulation levels from 1 to 100, additional boost stimulus from 1 to 60. The sensation is classified as 'blunt' instead of shock. It comes with lithium-polymer rechargeable batteries and dual charger.


PetSafe Yard & Park Rechargeable Dog Training Collar Review

PetSafe Yard & Park Rechargeable Dog Training Collar Review

Click for More Photos

Editor Rating:

PetSafe Yard Dog training device has the following specifications:

  • Trains up to 3 dogs.
  • 400 yard training range.
  • Waterproof up to 5 feet.
  • For dogs over 40 pounds.
  • 8 levels of stimulation and 2 tones.
  • Remote waterproof transmitter.
  • Rechargeable waterproof receiver.

If you have one of this hard to train, stubborn dogs, then the PetSafe Training Collar may be just what you need. This model uses static stimulations which are adjustable to up to 8 levels, as well as 2 tones to assist you in training and modifying their stubborn behavior. The tones are helpful as you slowly wean your dog off of the static stimulation so they respond to the tone only.

This affordable dog training device features a 4-1/2 ounce receiver collar with a 400 yard range, which works well for hiking or trips to the local dog park. The PetSafe Training Collar is waterproof up to 5 feet, which allows for training sessions at lakes, beaches or poolside safe.

If you have more than one dog, then this training system is your best bet, as you can train up to 3 dogs simultaneously, and with excellent results. However, additional collars are sold separately. This model is specifically designed for dogs 8 pounds and up, and neck sizes up to 28 inches. PetSafe cares about its customers and has customer care specialists available to answer questions 6 days a week.

The ergonomically designed transmitter is light and easy to hold. Your package includes a remote waterproof transmitter, rechargeable waterproof receiver, rechargeable NiMH batteries for both transmitter and receiver, charger and owners manual. This training device comes with a lifetime limited manufacturer's warranty.


  • Durable and easy to use.
  • Highly Affordable.
  • System can train up to 3 dogs.
  • Waterproof and rechargeable.
  • 8 static levels and praise and warning correction.


  • Range may be too short for some users.
  • The collar may be too stiff for your dog.

The PetSafe Yard & Park Rechargeable Dog Training Collar is a safe and effective way to train your dog. This model uses static signaling with low output signals. The PetSafe gives you 400 yards of range with 8 adjustable levels of static correction, has a rechargeable transmitter and receiver, is durable and waterproof. This training collar can assist in coming when called, jumping issues, bolting and pulling the leash. Overall, an excellent purchase for multiple dog households.


Pet Resolve Dog Training Kits Review (Best Dog Training Collar with Remote)

Pet Resolve best dog training collar

Click for More Images

Editor Rating:

Pet Resolve Dog training kit has the following specifications:

  • Comes in a package that consists of receiver, transmitter, battery charger, e-book, lanyard, spanner and prongs.
  • It is 100% waterproof.
  • It has 10 levels of shock and vibration.
  • Has a range of ¾ miles.
  • Suitable for large, medium and small dogs.

The Pet Resolve dog training kit with remote is one of the best dog training receiver and transmitters in the market. It can train up to 3 dogs at once; it comes with 10 shocks and vibrations which stimulate different behaviors.

It can control the collars from a distance of ¾ miles. It is suitable for both large, medium and small dogs. It comes with an eBook which contains instructions, the different settings and how to train your dog. The dog collar is completely waterproof and can withstand being submerged in water. This assures you that it can be used even when the dog is swimming or in the rain.

It has an ultra long lasting battery which is powered by a super high capacity Lithium ion battery. The battery is charged using the USB lead and adaptor. It takes 2 hours to be fully charged. Thanks to the 2 year warranty, you are assured of repairs or replacement in case it is damaged.


  • Both the collar and the transmitter are waterproof.
  • It comes with a USB adaptor and USB lead.
  • It takes only 2 hours to recharge fully.
  • It can control upto 3 dogs.
  • It comes with a free eBook.


  • The rechargeable battery can get depleted and lack of a backup will render the receiver useless.
  • It only comes with one lanyard while it has the capability of controlling 3 dogs.
  • You need to buy additional collars to controls more dogs.

The Pet Resolve dog training kit is great as you can control upto 3 dogs. It is powered by a rechargeable battery which takes 2 hours to be fully recharged. An eBook accompanies the kit which provides you with different techniques to train your dog. It is 100% waterproof and can be used to train large, medium and small dogs.


Lobo Commander Training Collar Review

Lobo Commander best training collars for dogs

Click for More Images

Editor Rating:

You May like Lobo Commander for the following Specifications:

  • Has 16 different correction levels
  • Has a lifetime warranty.
  • Has a 400 yard range.
  • Comes as a receiver and transmitter.
  • Can train two dogs at once with only one remote.

You can finally train your pet with the best dog training collar in the market. You can use it to help control bad behaviors like barking, chewing, jumping and running. Once you are done training the dog, it will be obedient and a great companion. You will finally be able to go with your dog anywhere you want without fear that your dog will misbehave.

It is fully rechargeable and has an LED battery indicator. When the charge starts to run low, the LED battery indicator on the collar will flash. You can be able to recharge it and ensure that your dog training exercises resume.

The remote comes with a belt clip and wrist lanyard. This makes it easy to carry around. The blue screen LCD display allows the dog owner to view different environments. The remote has different colored button which are used to elicit a specific stimulation.

The product has a lifetime warranty which assures the user of repairs and a replacement in case damage occurs.


  • It can fit all neck sizes from a 7 inch to a 27 inch dog neck.
  • It has an LED light that flashes when the battery level is low.
  • It allows for a 400 yard control range.
  • It has 16 levels of shock and vibration which improve dog behavior.
  • Can control up to two dogs using one remote.


  • You need to buy a separate collar in order to control more than one dog.
  • You need to recharge the battery every time the level goes down.
  • Does not provide control of the sound, vibration and static.

As the best dog training kit in the market, it is waterproof, rechargeable, has a 400 yard range with 16 levels of shock and vibration. They can be adjusted on the fly with no scrolling needed through the menus. It fits all neck sizes and comes with a belt clip and wrist lanyard for better handling.


Best Brands, Common Faqs & How to Use

Which are the best dog training collar brands?

Garmin Tri -best dog training collar brands

Garmin- The company is renowned as a GPS leader and today, it has entered the sporting dog community as well as revolutionizing dog track collars and coaching. They have developed innovative GPS dog tracking technology which has replaced the need of triangulating using old radio telemetry RF technology. Garmin acquired Tri-Tronics which has led to the development of dog collars with the best technology. This has made it easy to use and control. Their products are of high quality, reliable and simple to use.

Sportdog-best dog training collar brand

SportDog- This is one of the most recognized brands when it comes to dog collar training kits. It manufactures high quality products which are suitable for dogs of all ages. Their products are of value which assures you of savings and long term use. You can finally train your dog to be obedient within a short time thanks to this high quality product.

Dogtra Collar-best dog training collar brands

Dogtra- This company focuses on offering user friendly dog collars which can be controlled with a handheld remote device. They are suitable even for the most demanding situations for example when handling an aggressive dog. The company offers a wide range of dog collars and training kits which are suitable for a wide range of dogs.

Frequently Asked Questions.

1. How long will it take to train my dog?

This depends with the frequency of use. If you use it 10 minutes twice a day for two weeks, you should be able to modify the behavior of your dog.

2. Will the electric stimulation hurt my dog?

No, it will not harm your dog in any way. It is 100% safe and humane. The stimulation can be controlled using the handheld remote. The stimulation is designed to be unbearable for dogs in order to help them stop misbehaving.

3. How do I know which is the correct stimulation setting for my dog?

Most dog training kits come with an instruction manual. This provides different settings that will enable you to know when to use which. This makes it easier for you to train your dog according to a behavior you would like to change.

4. How old should my dog be before I use the dog collar?

It is recommended that your dog be at least 5 to 6 months before you start using the dog collar. It is important to ensure that your young dog can support the weight of the collar.

5. What kind of training is needed to use a dog training collar?

It is recommended that your dog be at least 5 to 6 months before you start using the dog collar. It is important to ensure that your young dog can support the weight of the collar.

How to use dog training collar?

Step One – Unwrap the content

Once you have purchased the kit using our dog collar zone buying guide, you can unwrap the contents. Set them aside and before starting to use, take a quick look at the instructions manual. This should be part of the package.

Step Two – Place the collar around your dog

Using the manual, you can test to see if the dog collar helps to train the dog. Since you are a newbie, the manual will guide you through the available buttons. It is important to start with the lowest settings just to get a feeling of how the dog collar works.

Step Three – Create a schedule

Once you have taken the dog collar for a test, it’s time for the real training. Depending with the behavior you would like your dog to kick out for example jumping, digging, chewing or barking, you can now begin training. When you press the appropriate button on the controller, it will send a small jolt which will be transmitted via contact points close to the dog’s skin. This will signify to the dog that the action done is not appropriate.

The Final Word

According to best dog training collar reviews, there are several things you need to consider when buying a dog training collar. This is done to ensure that what you have will benefit you and your dog. According to our buying guide, you need to consider factors like comfort, range, quality, stimulation modes, and battery type ad battery life among others.

Most dog training collars are designed to control more than one dog. To achieve this, the dog owner needs to buy different collars but they will be controlled by one handheld controller. This can be an affordable option for a dog owner with several dogs.

Finally, it is important to take time and research. Using our buying guide, you should be able to purchase a high quality product.

Other Posts You May Want to Read-

If you like the article please consider rating it-